Log in

View Full Version : Anti British and anti American threads - crass and boring


Ed
12-06-06, 11:10 PM
Nice posts. Ok I haven't read them all but I think it's safe to assume follows the usual pattern as in source , links , facts etc.

Anyways what I want ot know is
'Do the police have the powers to move the demonstrators on?' I only ask because they are interrupting traffic and being a general nuisance.

Look on the bright side though. I mean no one got killed and they have a big payout to look forward to.

Cheers
Ben

This is from the current terror thread. I couldn't agree with it more.

I am bored, I mean bored damn silly, with reading anti-British and anti-American threads on here. It's not what I come on here for. They're from the same people, time and time again. OK I know what you think and where you're coming from. You're entitled to your views. And I'm entitled to mine.

Course, I don't have to read them. But why shouldn't I? I make a few comments on some of them, just a few mind, to indicate that I have fairly conservative views, and generally I keep my head down. But the current one just sticks in my craw.

I shall be flamed as a corny, naive, narrow minded, ultra right wing, White Anglo-Saxon Protestant bigot. I don't really care any more, we have freedom of speech here in the United Kingdom, I'm free to say what I like, a luxury that so many others in the world don't have but would dearly aspire to. We have won it over a period of nearly 1,000 years. And this no doubt explains why the United Kingdom is such a popular haven for immigrants, for people who flee persecution in other less hospitable parts of the world. Perhaps this freedom of speech (for all the curtailments we have to put up with) is a peculiarly British concept, based largely on the defeat of European-style absolutist monarchical government in the early modern period, and the outcome of the English Civil War and its development in the Glorious Revolution in 1688 with the accession of William and Mary to the throne: an outcome that was developed by Abraham Lincoln and George Washington in the United States (a country for which, for all its faults, I have the profoundest admiration and respect), and an outcome which so many other cultures in the world find alien to their way of life.

Much as I hate the BNP and all it stands for, I can understand why they prosper, traditional British people are so fed up with the agenda being hijacked. We have to protect our way of life and we should not be afraid to do so simply because it's inconvenient to others, because others have a kneejerk reaction of 'racist' or 'imperialist'. I'm simply so fed up with the Establishment being bashed. When I was aged 16 - 24, I thought that the Establishment sucked. Put it down to the immaturity of youth. I grew up, got over it, moved on, learned what was more important to me and to other people - a stable, family-centred, loving home. I got married, in 1987, at age 26 to a beautiful woman who I loved, and whom I love to this day. The much-longed for kiddie took rather longer to arrive than we'd have liked, but in the end she did in 1998 - with a bit of perseverance :D and a few imaginative but ultimately very painful :( solutions along the way. I count myself lucky. And I thank my Christian God, every day, that so far I have landed on my feet. As Paul wrote to Timothy, 'For I can do all things through Him who gives me strength'.

So perhaps I shouldn't be surprised that there are others to replace me, the me as an immature and impressionable teenager. But this is a vitriol that I never had, I detect a hatred, a loathing, that wasn't me. I can only guess at where it comes from. Yes of course I don't live in today's Middle East, instead I'm smugly immune here in the sticks, in a leafy, rural and prosperous English county, immune from the horrors of life in what is now Iraq. A country that our American friends are turning into custard, as Gudster so memorably said on another of these threads. I don't have unconstitutional mullahs in Iran or Saudi Arabia or anywhere else telling me what to do and how to do it (I just have to account to the VAT-man, seems a small price to pay :roll: ).

And I feel proud, very proud, when a RAF Tornado flies overhead, because I help pay to train its crew, for the people who maintain it, and for it to stay up in the sky keeping the peace which, thanks to NATO, we here in the United Kingdom have learned to take for granted.

Perhaps, therefore, by proxy I'm part of this global Westernisation, this imposition of quasi-American ideals of freedom and democracy where they're not wanted, because I bankroll the corrupt British State to pursue its illegal wars. Perhaps by extension I'm responsible for slavery, and so perhaps I should apologise for that, too.

And then I read of British soldiers court-martialled for trying to do the impossible job of keeping the peace in a country that has only known savagery and fear for so long. Of their colleagues butcherered by a bloodthirsty mob at a police station in Basra, or blown up by a roadside bomb, simply for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Some of them lived close to here. And it makes me sick. And selfish me is glad that I'm not there, glad that I don't live in that hell-hole with all the chaos that so many brave British and American soldiers are doing their best to prevent, in the teeth of the most fervent and passionate opposition by people who post on forums such as this which can't logically be an appropriate place for their spleen, hate and fury, people who are following their own agenda for reasons best known to themselves, so that I can enjoy my fabulous British motorcycle that runs on Iraqi oil (after all, that was the purpose of the war wasn't it, so that I can continue to ride my bike on the cheap and on the back of other peoples' suffering, no???)

And then we have flawed intel that leads to raids on houses in London and occasionally in other places too. And people who are really innocent have their houses turned over. Of course I wouldn't like it if it happened to me. I acknowledge that.

And then we have a pile of people who criticise the slightest error of judgment, who jump on the bandwagon and create so much anti-police hysteria. Funny how these are largely the self-same as those I mention above, who oppose the liberation of peoples from years of repression. And Sir Ian Blair gets a toasting. How was it his fault???? He wasn't responsible. He is a good Christian man, and I respect his integrity. I choose not to speculate on the reasons for the raid.

But I do accept that if we are to keep at bay those who would otherwise blow us all to kingdom come given half the chance (and I don't doubt that there are a fair few of them in Guantanamo Bay) then we have to be prepared for this. Of course it ain't nice, nobody said it was. But it happens. People are human, so is Sir Ian Blair. And we get hordes of complaints from Muslims who say they're being picked on. It's complete BS, but no doubt some of that VAT I mentioned earlier will go on a fat payout to those concerned and will smooth ruffled feathers, and then they'll stop their bitching about how unfair life has become simply because they worship Mohammed instead of Jesus.

I think we need to remember where we have come from, why so many have come to this great land, and also to remember our American, Australian, New Zealand, Irish, Canadian, South African, Indian, Fijian, Norwegian and all other Allied friends who paid equally dearly for a free Europe and a free world 60 years ago. Because whether you like it or not - and it isn't at all PC to say so - if they hadn't, we wouldn't be free now. We'd probably have self-government, of a sort, as long as you spoke German and voted Nazi.

And we should remember from that, what we have come to. To a prosperity that our great-grandparents couldn't even dream of. And to remember that the threat from those who would destroy it is ever present.

gudster
12-06-06, 11:21 PM
well said, that man :smt038

BILLY
12-06-06, 11:30 PM
I totaly agree :smt038 :smt038 :smt038

northwind
12-06-06, 11:35 PM
Excellent post... I disagree with a lot of it mind, but still.

I think you'd find a lot of the people who you think are attacking the british way of life actually feel the same way as you, they just see the threat as different- or even that they agree with you, and see other threats. You've heard of "loyal opposition"? Myself, i think if there's a threat to freedom of speech, it's not just terrorism, it's what we do in response. I think if there's a threat to a community, it's people being squeezed out just because they're a target for abuse- you get no racism in an all-white community.

Of course, some people are just up for a fight, and some just hate the man, regardless of what he's doing the man is always wrong.

Richie
12-06-06, 11:55 PM
Well said Ed, that's one hell of a speech that would make me want to sign up for another 22 years to defend this Great Country of ours.

This country is changing, not for the better I might add, but as more people do not do anything about it and just agree as it not there responsibility, it is becoming more like "1984" George Orwell's PC Nanny state...

I'm English, I was born in England, That also means I'm British.. and if I choose to wear a St Georges flag or a Union Flag on a T-shirt or fly it from my house then I should be aloud to, as that is my Patron St & my nations Flag.
In some places I'm not to be aloud to wear it or Fly it as it might cause some friction as it's not PC...FFS This is the United Kingdom... Be proud. I signed on for Queen and Country to Defend our Flag, wear it / Fly it with pride.


BTW this is only my view, and I hope yours too.

sorry Ed if this is not the sort reply you had intended, but after reading your post I just had to get this off my chest.

amarko5
13-06-06, 01:17 AM
:thumbsup:

no need to say owt :lol:

Lissa
13-06-06, 06:03 AM
Nice posts. Ok I haven't read them all but I think it's safe to assume follows the usual pattern as in source , links , facts etc.

Anyways what I want ot know is
'Do the police have the powers to move the demonstrators on?' I only ask because they are interrupting traffic and being a general nuisance.

Look on the bright side though. I mean no one got killed and they have a big payout to look forward to.

Cheers
Ben

This is from the current terror thread. I couldn't agree with it more.

I am bored, I mean bored damn silly, with reading anti-British and anti-American threads on here. It's not what I come on here for. They're from the same people, time and time again. OK I know what you think and where you're coming from. You're entitled to your views. And I'm entitled to mine.

Course, I don't have to read them. But why shouldn't I? I make a few comments on some of them, just a few mind, to indicate that I have fairly conservative views, and generally I keep my head down. But the current one just sticks in my craw.

I shall be flamed as a corny, naive, narrow minded, ultra right wing, White Anglo-Saxon Protestant bigot. I don't really care any more, we have freedom of speech here in the United Kingdom, I'm free to say what I like, a luxury that so many others in the world don't have but would dearly aspire to. We have won it over a period of nearly 1,000 years. And this no doubt explains why the United Kingdom is such a popular haven for immigrants, for people who flee persecution in other less hospitable parts of the world. Perhaps this freedom of speech (for all the curtailments we have to put up with) is a peculiarly British concept, based largely on the defeat of European-style absolutist monarchical government in the early modern period, and the outcome of the English Civil War and its development in the Glorious Revolution in 1688 with the accession of William and Mary to the throne: an outcome that was developed by Abraham Lincoln and George Washington in the United States (a country for which, for all its faults, I have the profoundest admiration and respect), and an outcome which so many other cultures in the world find alien to their way of life.

Much as I hate the BNP and all it stands for, I can understand why they prosper, traditional British people are so fed up with the agenda being hijacked. We have to protect our way of life and we should not be afraid to do so simply because it's inconvenient to others, because others have a kneejerk reaction of 'racist' or 'imperialist'. I'm simply so fed up with the Establishment being bashed. When I was aged 16 - 24, I thought that the Establishment sucked. Put it down to the immaturity of youth. I grew up, got over it, moved on, learned what was more important to me and to other people - a stable, family-centred, loving home. I got married, in 1987, at age 26 to a beautiful woman who I loved, and whom I love to this day. The much-longed for kiddie took rather longer to arrive than we'd have liked, but in the end she did in 1998 - with a bit of perseverance :D and a few imaginative but ultimately very painful :( solutions along the way. I count myself lucky. And I thank my Christian God, every day, that so far I have landed on my feet. As Paul wrote to Timothy, 'For I can do all things through Him who gives me strength'.

So perhaps I shouldn't be surprised that there are others to replace me, the me as an immature and impressionable teenager. But this is a vitriol that I never had, I detect a hatred, a loathing, that wasn't me. I can only guess at where it comes from. Yes of course I don't live in today's Middle East, instead I'm smugly immune here in the sticks, in a leafy, rural and prosperous English county, immune from the horrors of life in what is now Iraq. A country that our American friends are turning into custard, as Gudster so memorably said on another of these threads. I don't have unconstitutional mullahs in Iran or Saudi Arabia or anywhere else telling me what to do and how to do it (I just have to account to the VAT-man, seems a small price to pay :roll: ).

And I feel proud, very proud, when a RAF Tornado flies overhead, because I help pay to train its crew, for the people who maintain it, and for it to stay up in the sky keeping the peace which, thanks to NATO, we here in the United Kingdom have learned to take for granted.

Perhaps, therefore, by proxy I'm part of this global Westernisation, this imposition of quasi-American ideals of freedom and democracy where they're not wanted, because I bankroll the corrupt British State to pursue its illegal wars. Perhaps by extension I'm responsible for slavery, and so perhaps I should apologise for that, too.

And then I read of British soldiers court-martialled for trying to do the impossible job of keeping the peace in a country that has only known savagery and fear for so long. Of their colleagues butcherered by a bloodthirsty mob at a police station in Basra, or blown up by a roadside bomb, simply for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Some of them lived close to here. And it makes me sick. And selfish me is glad that I'm not there, glad that I don't live in that hell-hole with all the chaos that so many brave British and American soldiers are doing their best to prevent, in the teeth of the most fervent and passionate opposition by people who post on forums such as this which can't logically be an appropriate place for their spleen, hate and fury, people who are following their own agenda for reasons best known to themselves, so that I can enjoy my fabulous British motorcycle that runs on Iraqi oil (after all, that was the purpose of the war wasn't it, so that I can continue to ride my bike on the cheap and on the back of other peoples' suffering, no???)

And then we have flawed intel that leads to raids on houses in London and occasionally in other places too. And people who are really innocent have their houses turned over. Of course I wouldn't like it if it happened to me. I acknowledge that.

And then we have a pile of people who criticise the slightest error of judgment, who jump on the bandwagon and create so much anti-police hysteria. Funny how these are largely the self-same as those I mention above, who oppose the liberation of peoples from years of repression. And Sir Ian Blair gets a toasting. How was it his fault???? He wasn't responsible. He is a good Christian man, and I respect his integrity. I choose not to speculate on the reasons for the raid.

But I do accept that if we are to keep at bay those who would otherwise blow us all to kingdom come given half the chance (and I don't doubt that there are a fair few of them in Guantanamo Bay) then we have to be prepared for this. Of course it ain't nice, nobody said it was. But it happens. People are human, so is Sir Ian Blair. And we get hordes of complaints from Muslims who say they're being picked on. It's complete BS, but no doubt some of that VAT I mentioned earlier will go on a fat payout to those concerned and will smooth ruffled feathers, and then they'll stop their bitching about how unfair life has become simply because they worship Mohammed instead of Jesus.

I think we need to remember where we have come from, why so many have come to this great land, and also to remember our American, Australian, New Zealand, Irish, Canadian, South African, Indian, Fijian, Norwegian and all other Allied friends who paid equally dearly for a free Europe and a free world 60 years ago. Because whether you like it or not - and it isn't at all PC to say so - if they hadn't, we wouldn't be free now. We'd probably have self-government, of a sort, as long as you spoke German and voted Nazi.

And we should remember from that, what we have come to. To a prosperity that our great-grandparents couldn't even dream of. And to remember that the threat from those who would destroy it is ever present.

:winner:

Best post I've read all year, and I couldn't agree more.

Peter Henry
13-06-06, 06:09 AM
In essence I agree with you Ed. There are as you say a few flies in the ointment who will no doubt seek to continue their particular rhetoric right here on the back of this thread. :wink:

Stingo
13-06-06, 06:32 AM
some stuff
Cheers
Ben

This is from the current terror thread. I couldn't agree with it more.

Lots of stuff, finishing with...

And we should remember from that, what we have come to. To a prosperity that our great-grandparents couldn't even dream of. And to remember that the threat from those who would destroy it is ever present.


Imagine my surprise when I logged on and found this...everything I've ever wanted to say but didn't have the eloquence or ability to put into words. Brilliant. Stand up and be counted. You can never please all of the people all of the time...but hey...take this in the spirit in which it is meant...and celebrate.

:smt038

dirtydog
13-06-06, 07:09 AM
an excellent post :smt038 :smt038

21QUEST
13-06-06, 07:33 AM
Whao..... Ed =D> .

Excellent post.

Cheers
Ben

Flamin_Squirrel
13-06-06, 08:00 AM
Unfortuately Ed, we don't have freedom of speach at all. You're not free to say whatever you like.

This is part of the problem. If you asked people if they thought this country was becoming more or less tollerant, most would probably say more. I would disagree with this. People have become so intollerant that you cant smoke, cant go hunting or own a gun, you're not free to say what you think or even protest in front of parlament anymore.

I dont think there's anti-british sentiment on this forum so much as anti-government. Makes me wonder how Labour have retained power for so long, but then I think most people on this forum realise it's never a good idea to let any political party retain power as long as this government has as they always become evil and tyranical.

sharriso74
13-06-06, 08:07 AM
Evil and tyranical because you can't own or gun or chase foxes with hounds and horses don't think so.

Self serving, arrogant and misguided yes. Same as with the Tories when they where in for too long.

Jelster
13-06-06, 08:14 AM
Well said Ed, my sentiments entirely....

.

keithd
13-06-06, 08:15 AM
Unfortuately Ed, we don't have freedom of speach at all. You're not free to say whatever you like.

are we not? since when?

This is part of the problem. If you asked people if they thought this country was becoming more or less tollerant, most would probably say more. I would disagree with this. People have become so intollerant that you cant smoke, cant go hunting or own a gun, you're not free to say what you think or even protest in front of parlament anymore.

now there's a ****ing surprise....

Flamin_Squirrel
13-06-06, 08:23 AM
Evil and tyranical because you can't own or gun or chase foxes with hounds and horses don't think so.

Self serving, arrogant and misguided yes. Same as with the Tories when they where in for too long.

Yeah I s'pose. Results the same though.

Unfortuately Ed, we don't have freedom of speach at all. You're not free to say whatever you like.

are we not? since when?

Dress up in a white sheet and say how much you dont like coloured people and you'll get arrested.

This is part of the problem. If you asked people if they thought this country was becoming more or less tollerant, most would probably say more. I would disagree with this. People have become so intollerant that you cant smoke, cant go hunting or own a gun, you're not free to say what you think or even protest in front of parlament anymore.

now there's a f*cking surprise....

:roll:

Droc
13-06-06, 09:17 AM
Can anybody summarise it for me?

Just a quick question though Ed - Can you explain to me how your Christian God beliefs are compatible with condoning illegal wars?

akbarhussain
13-06-06, 09:19 AM
Can anybody summarise it for me?

Just a quick question though Ed - Can you explain to me how your Christian God beliefs are compatible with condoning illegal wars?


I knew it!!!! I just knew it after reading that rant that we had a religous zealot on our hands. lol.

But good question Droc, very interested in hearing your answer Ed..........

sharriso74
13-06-06, 09:22 AM
Name one religon that advocates violence. Unless it's been distorted by those with their own agenda

tricky
13-06-06, 09:29 AM
I probably going to regret this but here goes.
Have you ever wondered why Muslims / Arabs feel picked upon ?

Look at what happened to the middle east at the end of the first world war.

When Isreal invaded Palestine and UN resolutions where passed for them to get out what did the USA do ?

Then contrast this with actions of the UK and the USA when Iraq is (allegedly) in contravention of UN resolutions over WMD's.

The west provided support to Saddam Hussain to the Mujahideen to fight against Russia and Iran, the word "puppet" springs to mind.

Where are UK and US forces now deployed and who are they fighting against ?

I am not defending the actions of terrorists or extremists.
I deplore violence and to kill or use violence in the name of God (whatever you call him) sickens and upsets me more than I can describe.

akbarhussain
13-06-06, 09:31 AM
Name one religon that advocates violence. Unless it's been distorted by those with their own agenda

Who wa sthe question aimed at Sharriso?

Razor
13-06-06, 09:35 AM
Name one religon that advocates violence. Unless it's been distorted by those with their own agenda

Satanism! Now what did I win? :smt077

akbarhussain
13-06-06, 09:40 AM
Cristianity (http://atheism.about.com/b/a/076033.htm)

Sid Squid
13-06-06, 09:41 AM
Laughing with you Akbar, with you.

Razor
13-06-06, 09:43 AM
I can't help think that an athiest website isn't the best place to get unbiased religious opinion. Get a sound file of the Pope screaming "Kill 'em all" and I'll be more convinced.

akbarhussain
13-06-06, 09:46 AM
Christianity (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusades)

sharriso74
13-06-06, 09:50 AM
Christianity (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusades)

As said religon thst hasn't been distorted

Razor
13-06-06, 09:51 AM
Where's my Pope sound file???

Ancient history does not take into account how christianity has evolved and continues to do so.

Wanna see a vid of a hostage having their head sawed off while people shout "Allah akbar"?

Far more recent and pertinent to any subject you wish to discuss.

akbarhussain
13-06-06, 09:52 AM
Christianity (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusades)

As said religon thst hasn't been distorted

My apoligies, I didn't see that bit of your post.

akbarhussain
13-06-06, 09:54 AM
Where's my Pope sound file???

Ancient history does not take into account how christianity has evolved and continues to do so.

Wanna see a vid of a hostage having their head sawed off while people shout "Allah akbar"?

Far more recent and pertinent to any subject you wish to discuss.

As said religon thst hasn't been distorted



Wanna see a vid of a hostage having their head sawed off while people shout "Allah akbar"?

You mean those created/marketed by the CIA?

Razor
13-06-06, 09:57 AM
You mean those created/marketed by the CIA?



Careful, they could be watching you right now.
Black helicopters mointoring your every move!
How do you sleep at night knowing they're out to get you?

21QUEST
13-06-06, 11:14 AM
You sometimes I find it funny how sometimes it's the Intollerant that want to scream the most.
It's like an unbelieveable holywood movie. Looks like magic.

Cheers
Ben

northwind
13-06-06, 11:25 AM
Unfortuately Ed, we don't have freedom of speach at all. You're not free to say whatever you like.

are we not? since when?


Libel and tort... Breach of the peace. Incitement to riot, incitement to commit racial hatred, subjudicy, the Official Secrets Act... And I think the Prevention of Terrorism Act, the Criminal Justice Act 94, and of course "Freedom of speech doesn't protect your right to shout FIRE in a crowded theatre" (one of my favourite quotes, anyone know where it originates?)

keithd
13-06-06, 11:32 AM
Unfortuately Ed, we don't have freedom of speach at all. You're not free to say whatever you like.

are we not? since when?


Libel and tort... Breach of the peace. Incitement to riot, incitement to commit racial hatred, subjudicy, the Official Secrets Act... And I think the Prevention of Terrorism Act, the Criminal Justice Act 94, and of course "Freedom of speech doesn't protect your right to shout FIRE in a crowded theatre" (one of my favourite quotes, anyone know where it originates?)

jeez talk about taking things to a ridiculous degree! you know whats meant by the term freedom of speech, your right to talk absolute bollox and not be attacked or persecuted for it. "you're talking rubbish sir, but i will defend to the death your right to do so." to paraphrase a well known quote.

but i'll never win this one so, ok you both win.

Shinsei Jutsu
13-06-06, 11:35 AM
nah, I'm with you on this one Keith. We have freedom of speech, we don't have freedom to preach and stand on a soap box and abuse races/religions/monarcy, but then that isn't what you were talking about.

sharriso74
13-06-06, 11:40 AM
What the world needs is a great big :grouphug:

northwind
13-06-06, 12:17 PM
but i'll never win this one so, ok you both win.

Not a case of winning mate, I actually agree with you here ;) Just putting out a wee thing to say that there's no total free speech in the UK, and hasn't been for as long as there's been any sort of civil law. Not my intention to beat you down or anything, sorry about that!

keithd
13-06-06, 12:20 PM
but i'll never win this one so, ok you both win.

Not a case of winning mate, I actually agree with you here ;) Just putting out a wee thing to say that there's no total free speech in the UK, and hasn't been for as long as there's been any sort of civil law. Not my intention to beat you down or anything, sorry about that!

no worries, i just mistook the tone of the message

love you :wink:

northwind
13-06-06, 12:27 PM
That's all I ask, total obedience and love.

Speedy
13-06-06, 05:49 PM
Ed,I couldn't agree with you more!

I now understand what all the hubbub is about in the thread by Admiral Akbar!

Glad there are some people left who stand-up for what they believe in!

Bloody good thread! :thumbsup: :winner:

Xerbraski
13-06-06, 06:08 PM
I probably going to regret this but here goes.
Have you ever wondered why Muslims / Arabs feel picked upon ?

Look at what happened to the middle east at the end of the first world war.

When Isreal invaded Palestine and UN resolutions where passed for them to get out what did the USA do ?

Then contrast this with actions of the UK and the USA when Iraq is (allegedly) in contravention of UN resolutions over WMD's.

The west provided support to Saddam Hussain to the Mujahideen to fight against Russia and Iran, the word "puppet" springs to mind.

Where are UK and US forces now deployed and who are they fighting against ?

I am not defending the actions of terrorists or extremists.
I deplore violence and to kill or use violence in the name of God (whatever you call him) sickens and upsets me more than I can describe.

Not forgetting the Crusades!!! (christians)