View Full Version : Most consistently accurate weather site....
Which is it? Sure isnt the BBC who probably just guess it - I've never known them to be right yet! Someone recommended Metcheck to me - any good?
For UK weather there can only be one:
http://www.metoffice.com/
They are world experts in forecasting, never mind just for the uk, and they supply data to many other websites.
With regard to accuracy, it depends how a website presents it's data for a daily forecast. Some give an average over a 24-hour period, others give the worst case. The BBC's 24-hour forecast is pretty-good in my experience, particularly since it is broken into 3-hour blocks.
kwak zzr
19-08-07, 02:37 PM
they all get it wrong.
tigersaw
19-08-07, 02:39 PM
Gotta agree about the BBC - you can go to bed with bright sunshine for tomorrow to find they have changed to p*ssing down by the morning. They are consistantly wrong. Odd thing is we here at the airport provide them with met data and trends, and they even get it wrong when you wind the animation back.
Wideboy
19-08-07, 03:04 PM
the one the RAF use is meant to be the best but i forgot it :(
Excellent, looks like I might have good weather the next few days for my trip to Ecosse.
Tim in Belgium
19-08-07, 04:06 PM
Have a good trip Rob, and try and remember the good roads, I'm heading up thatway for the bank holiday weekend.
muffles
19-08-07, 06:17 PM
It's definitely not the BBC!
I actually was bored one day a couple of months back and I put an official complaint in. Apparently they source all their data from the Met Office, and cc'd the Met Office in the reply to ask them to explain further about why the data is always so far off.
They didn't really explain except to say that due to variations they are only 65% correct by the fifth day (there are 5-day and 24-hour forecasts on the BBC). I was like this :rolleyes: when I read that, until I realised they probably base it on those 3 hour blocks (or maybe even more granular) - so if they get 1 block correct, they claim to be correct for the day.
It must be this cos they aren't even 65% correct for the 1st day :rolleyes: - for example, on Monday it said that Saturday was a 'full sun' symbol. And when I looked on Friday, it was a double rain, black cloud!
Here is the method the Met Office use to predict the weather:
http://www.am1340.com/images/GarysWeatherSign2.jpg
arenalife
19-08-07, 06:26 PM
I think the 5 day BBC site is exellent and I use it all the time, accuracy is about 75% for me.
I think you'd be incredibly naive to use any day version where it says rain at 10 and sun at 12 etc.
muffles
19-08-07, 07:30 PM
I don't use it for anything, it's rubbish, but I would have expected it to be more accurate predicting the weather in a few hours than in a few days. They presumably agree since they blabbered on to me about how it's only 65% accurate by the 5th day. I'm surprised you are getting that much accuracy! Out of interest what did it predict for this weekend, was it correct? Since it was the complete opposite of what they predicted for me - of course they have "updated" it so on Friday it actually said Saturday was rain. As I say, they use Gary's forecasting stone - to predict as accurately as the BBC, look outside, it's that weather for the next 5 days...
Cloggsy
19-08-07, 07:53 PM
For UK weather there can only be one:
http://www.metoffice.com/
They are world experts in forecasting, never mind just for the uk, and they supply data to many other websites.
With regard to accuracy, it depends how a website presents it's data for a daily forecast. Some give an average over a 24-hour period, others give the worst case. The BBC's 24-hour forecast is pretty-good in my experience, particularly since it is broken into 3-hour blocks.
Surely you mean www.metoffice.gov.uk :?:
portreekid
19-08-07, 11:25 PM
Metcheck fairly good
www.theyr.tv (http://www.theyr.tv) Faroese site, VERY accurate, is a subscription site but has free 14 day trial. We use this one as a guide in the North Sea (where you really do want accurate info especially in Winter)but covers whole of Europe. Probably the most accurate I've come accross.
www.magicseaweed.com (http://www.magicseaweed.com) this one though is more for conditions at sea but wind speeds etc again proven to be very accurate. (Think this one a big favourite with surfers, very accurate swell info)
Pedro68
20-08-07, 09:03 AM
My own personal experience of the BBC weather site is this:
5-day forecast changes day-by-day, so take with LARGE pinch of salt ;-)
24-hour forecast is usually fairly good. Granted, not 100% accurate, but not bad really.
I've been using the BBC weather site for several months now, but I also check both the BBC and ITV weather on breakfast TV. The more sources of information, the better ;-)
Pete
markmoto
20-08-07, 09:21 AM
At the end of the day no one can tell the future a forcast is always going to be an educated guess, they may be able to get the next day correct but as the time goes on the the possibilities of change go up and up.
Steve_God
20-08-07, 12:17 PM
For that day I use: http://www.bbc.co.uk/weather/ukweather/rain.shtml
Purely as it gives me a better visual idea if it's going to rain or not, and more importantly, WHERE the rain cloud is going - which is all the weather forecasters can do, give you an idea.
End of the day, if a cloud is gonna drop its load, it's going to where it wants, not always where it's expected.
Surely you mean www.metoffice.gov.uk (http://www.metoffice.gov.uk) :?:
Both work!
vBulletin® , Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.