One For Peter Henry - SV650.org

08-11-06, 04:45 PM

Is Valentino Rossi the greatest rider of all time?

08-11-06, 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve H

Sorry, could not resist.

resist what?

Biker Biggles · 08-11-06, 04:59 PM

where's the yes option?

08-11-06, 05:01 PM

If he was the greatest he wouldn't have fallen off at Valencia

08-11-06, 05:19 PM

Rossi is a p*ssy.

When he wins a few TT's we can start discussing whether he is more of a man than Mike the Bike.

09-11-06, 09:07 AM

Rather odd question and dubious basis for a poll in my opinion. Valentino Rossi is for sure an extremely talented motorcycle racer and a one off character. The greatest of all time? Who knows? It is very difficult to compare with brilliant riders from other era's and no correct answer can be given to that.

As good as Valentino is I am presently pondering whether in fact his record may now begin to indicate that his best days have now gone? Maybe not of course but there are several other riders who have not reached their peak yet and have shown that they can push Rossi already, not beat him perhaps but certainly test him.

As they improve can Valentino take his skills to greater heights still than have been needed before?

I think many on this forum misread my view of Valentino entirely. I am though willing to step out of the loop when discussing him.

09-11-06, 09:30 AM

Peter only joking mate. You are entitled to your opinion...........(Christ knows, thats all I give on here!

)
I myself am amazed at the achievements of yer man Vale, but would not say I am
the worlds biggest fan!
Steven

09-11-06, 01:24 PM

I answered Yes. Am I bad? Am I in trouble?

timwilky · 09-11-06, 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve H

Is Valentino Rossi the greatest rider of all time?

Nah, he is still a puppy. To be the greatest of all time he has to beat the records of the likes of Giacomo Agostini.

I reckon the Camila's legendary Uncle Edgar could would give Rossi a riding lesson on the island. However Joey Dunlops island record will never be beaten

09-11-06, 06:58 PM

I think there is more to it than the actual racing.
It is also the ability to ride a bike for 10 laps, then get back to the engineers and say "well on this corner, on this lap, this happened" which they can match up to the telemetry and so do something about it.
The great F1 drivers (Senna, Schumacher etc) could all do it, hence their results. The also-rans such as Mansell couldn't.

Not that I'm really qualified, but I do think VR is good.

View Poll Results: Is Vale the greatest?
YES	8	38.10%
YES	3	14.29%
YES	3	14.29%
Ummm... No.	7	33.33%
Voters: 21. You may not vote on this poll

08-11-06, 04:45 PM	#1
Steve H Guest Posts: n/a	One For Peter Henry Is Valentino Rossi the greatest rider of all time?

08-11-06, 04:59 PM	#3
Biker Biggles Member Mega Poster Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Barnet Herts Posts: 5,070	where's the yes option? __________________ On a clear day we stand there and look further than the ordinary eye can see.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Peter Henry he very sad.	Pedrosa	Bikes - Talk & Issues	27	23-04-07 01:46 PM
Oi Peter Henry.	Biker Biggles	Idle Banter	40	09-03-07 09:57 AM
FAO Peter Henry - nobody else need bother !!	Supervox	Bikes - Talk & Issues	11	18-10-06 08:33 PM
Oi Peter Henry	Supervox	Idle Banter	6	13-07-06 11:03 AM
FAO Peter Henry - nobody else need bother !!	Black widow	Idle Banter	5	08-01-70 07:45 PM

08-11-06, 05:01 PM	#4
BILLY Guest Posts: n/a	If he was the greatest he wouldn't have fallen off at Valencia

08-11-06, 05:19 PM	#5
Toypop Guest Posts: n/a	Rossi is a p*ssy. When he wins a few TT's we can start discussing whether he is more of a man than Mike the Bike.

09-11-06, 09:07 AM	#6
Peter Henry Guest Posts: n/a	Rather odd question and dubious basis for a poll in my opinion. Valentino Rossi is for sure an extremely talented motorcycle racer and a one off character. The greatest of all time? Who knows? It is very difficult to compare with brilliant riders from other era's and no correct answer can be given to that. As good as Valentino is I am presently pondering whether in fact his record may now begin to indicate that his best days have now gone? Maybe not of course but there are several other riders who have not reached their peak yet and have shown that they can push Rossi already, not beat him perhaps but certainly test him. As they improve can Valentino take his skills to greater heights still than have been needed before? I think many on this forum misread my view of Valentino entirely. I am though willing to step out of the loop when discussing him.

09-11-06, 09:30 AM	#7
Steve H Guest Posts: n/a	Peter only joking mate. You are entitled to your opinion...........(Christ knows, thats all I give on here! ) I myself am amazed at the achievements of yer man Vale, but would not say I am the worlds biggest fan! Steven

09-11-06, 01:24 PM	#8
M65 Guest Posts: n/a	I answered Yes. Am I bad? Am I in trouble?

09-11-06, 06:58 PM	#10
rpwoodman Guest Posts: n/a	I think there is more to it than the actual racing. It is also the ability to ride a bike for 10 laps, then get back to the engineers and say "well on this corner, on this lap, this happened" which they can match up to the telemetry and so do something about it. The great F1 drivers (Senna, Schumacher etc) could all do it, hence their results. The also-rans such as Mansell couldn't. Not that I'm really qualified, but I do think VR is good.