Blackberry vs iPhone? - SV650.org

slloyd · 15-06-09, 10:01 AM

We are in the process of changing our office mobile phone contract to 02, and the telling question is do we continue using the BES or switch to the iphone handsets.

I've not had any dealings with an iphone, and only what I've searched for on the web, so I wanted to know what pro's & cons are given between the 2 handsets.

What I've heard that if the iphone is locked, you are unable to see your email/sms notifications and the push email only updates every 15 minutes, and not like the blackberry where it is instant.

Anyone, gone from Blackberry to iphone? your comments would be greatfully received.

SoulKiss · 15-06-09, 10:06 AM

Wouldn't touch either.

iPhone - locked POS thats all style, no substance.

Blackberry - what is so important that you need to see an email the second it is recieved and is it REALLY worth the back-end cost/hassle.

Any phone that supports IMAP/POP3 email can be set to check for new messages every x minutes and with large data packages available, the excess traffic this generates isn't a problem.

Me, I use an N95 which when I am worried about it, checks for email every 5 mins, when I am not, I manually update it.

But then again, I use the phone, I dont let it use me/run my life.

G · 15-06-09, 10:08 AM

Blackberry for business.

IPhone for pleasure, if at all.

slloyd · 15-06-09, 10:12 AM

SK; unfortunately Architects like Gadgets especially the guys in my office, and they have been using Blackberries without cause for concern - but it's when they go on "Client Day Outs" and the client pulls a iphone and says look what this can do...yada,yada,yada -everyone gets a bee in there bonnet and wants an iphone.

I keep trying to tell them it's not a fashion item - and the Blackberry does the job that is required.

Plus, with the NEW 3G iphone dropping on our shores on Wednesday, I want to be sure of my decisions against the iphone and/or blackberry

pookie · 15-06-09, 10:29 AM

i have installed base of both BES and MS push email. We moved new users to MS as they could use their iphones. Configuration on the exchange server was simple and runs seamlessly alongside the BES. The top brass are still on Blackberrys. Why dont you suggest having it in parallel?

slloyd · 15-06-09, 10:44 AM

pookie...that is one of the suggestions that is going to get mentioned just to put this issue to bed to be honest with you.

slloyd · 15-06-09, 11:11 AM

pookie...do any of your users have issues with the iphone email push facility?

15-06-09, 11:59 AM

I'd say MS Exchange push too. Then you can use any windows mobile handset along side the iPhone should you want to.

I'm not a windows person though, so my opinion might be bad. I got given a blackberry and it seems to work. It annoys the hell out of me though, and I would rather have an iPhone.

Dan

pookie · 15-06-09, 02:22 PM

I know i was asked to support iphone cos the user wanted to go up the mountains skiing. I dont think they user is too bothered about the emails more just he wanted connectivity. Once setup it works the same for all the windows mobile phones

15-06-09, 05:53 PM

iphone but wait another week the 3gs comes out , looks the nuts , iv got the 3g and cant say a bad thing about it .

15-06-09, 10:01 AM	#1
slloyd Member Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: At Work...Most of the time :-( Posts: 276	Blackberry vs iPhone? We are in the process of changing our office mobile phone contract to 02, and the telling question is do we continue using the BES or switch to the iphone handsets. I've not had any dealings with an iphone, and only what I've searched for on the web, so I wanted to know what pro's & cons are given between the 2 handsets. What I've heard that if the iphone is locked, you are unable to see your email/sms notifications and the push email only updates every 15 minutes, and not like the blackberry where it is instant. Anyone, gone from Blackberry to iphone? your comments would be greatfully received. __________________ 2002 Silver SV650S K2 - Sold. 2013 Black Triumph STR - Stolen 2007 Black SV650S K7 - "Suzy" Pointy, Carbon Can Co Exhaust, and Body Colour Bellypan - Hopefully a long romance...

15-06-09, 10:06 AM	#2
SoulKiss Member Mega Poster Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Sunny Croydonia Posts: 6,124	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? Wouldn't touch either. iPhone - locked POS thats all style, no substance. Blackberry - what is so important that you need to see an email the second it is recieved and is it REALLY worth the back-end cost/hassle. Any phone that supports IMAP/POP3 email can be set to check for new messages every x minutes and with large data packages available, the excess traffic this generates isn't a problem. Me, I use an N95 which when I am worried about it, checks for email every 5 mins, when I am not, I manually update it. But then again, I use the phone, I dont let it use me/run my life. __________________ Sent from my PC NOT using any Tapatalk type rubbish!! █╬╬╬╬(•)i¯i▀▀▀▀▀█Ξ███████████████████████████████)

15-06-09, 10:08 AM	#3
G Member Mega Poster Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 3,770	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? Blackberry for business. IPhone for pleasure, if at all. __________________ 6.67300 × 10-11 m3 kg-1 s-2

15-06-09, 10:12 AM	#4
slloyd Member Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: At Work...Most of the time :-( Posts: 276	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? SK; unfortunately Architects like Gadgets especially the guys in my office, and they have been using Blackberries without cause for concern - but it's when they go on "Client Day Outs" and the client pulls a iphone and says look what this can do...yada,yada,yada -everyone gets a bee in there bonnet and wants an iphone. I keep trying to tell them it's not a fashion item - and the Blackberry does the job that is required. Plus, with the NEW 3G iphone dropping on our shores on Wednesday, I want to be sure of my decisions against the iphone and/or blackberry __________________ 2002 Silver SV650S K2 - Sold. 2013 Black Triumph STR - Stolen 2007 Black SV650S K7 - "Suzy" Pointy, Carbon Can Co Exhaust, and Body Colour Bellypan - Hopefully a long romance...

15-06-09, 10:29 AM	#5
pookie Member Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: Essex Posts: 938	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? i have installed base of both BES and MS push email. We moved new users to MS as they could use their iphones. Configuration on the exchange server was simple and runs seamlessly alongside the BES. The top brass are still on Blackberrys. Why dont you suggest having it in parallel? __________________ "an unedifying exercise in postmodern, operatic grunge" Was - 2000 Candy blue sv650s -2003 Sonic silver sv1000s Gone - 2007 Wildfire Orange Ninja zx6r Now - 2010 Triton blue sv650s -Back to the future

15-06-09, 10:44 AM	#6
slloyd Member Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: At Work...Most of the time :-( Posts: 276	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? pookie...that is one of the suggestions that is going to get mentioned just to put this issue to bed to be honest with you. __________________ 2002 Silver SV650S K2 - Sold. 2013 Black Triumph STR - Stolen 2007 Black SV650S K7 - "Suzy" Pointy, Carbon Can Co Exhaust, and Body Colour Bellypan - Hopefully a long romance...

15-06-09, 11:11 AM	#7
slloyd Member Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: At Work...Most of the time :-( Posts: 276	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? pookie...do any of your users have issues with the iphone email push facility? __________________ 2002 Silver SV650S K2 - Sold. 2013 Black Triumph STR - Stolen 2007 Black SV650S K7 - "Suzy" Pointy, Carbon Can Co Exhaust, and Body Colour Bellypan - Hopefully a long romance...

15-06-09, 11:59 AM	#8
Sudoxe Guest Posts: n/a	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? I'd say MS Exchange push too. Then you can use any windows mobile handset along side the iPhone should you want to. I'm not a windows person though, so my opinion might be bad. I got given a blackberry and it seems to work. It annoys the hell out of me though, and I would rather have an iPhone. Dan Last edited by Sudoxe; 15-06-09 at 12:00 PM.

15-06-09, 02:22 PM	#9
pookie Member Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: Essex Posts: 938	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? I know i was asked to support iphone cos the user wanted to go up the mountains skiing. I dont think they user is too bothered about the emails more just he wanted connectivity. Once setup it works the same for all the windows mobile phones __________________ "an unedifying exercise in postmodern, operatic grunge" Was - 2000 Candy blue sv650s -2003 Sonic silver sv1000s Gone - 2007 Wildfire Orange Ninja zx6r Now - 2010 Triton blue sv650s -Back to the future

15-06-09, 05:53 PM	#10
jans1971 Guest Posts: n/a	Re: Blackberry vs iPhone? iphone but wait another week the 3gs comes out , looks the nuts , iv got the 3g and cant say a bad thing about it .

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Selling Blackberry!	Neeja	Idle Banter	0	27-07-08 05:34 PM
Unlocking Blackberry	Neeja	Idle Banter	0	25-07-08 12:07 PM