Reeder

That's actually pretty interesting and no doubt open to endless debate. I'm kind of sitting on the fence for this one.
I can see why they think it's right to do to him as what he did to her, especially as it was just because she wouldn't let him hit on her basically... what he did was exceedingly harsh and deserves an extreme punishment as he has definitely ruined her life.
At the same time I can see the same side as numbers man & realise that it isn't actually going to achieve much. It'll just then be another blind person, who feels exceedingly bitter and sorry for himself. Will most likely never be a productive citizen for the rest of his time alive.