Blood transfusions?

[Tom_the_great]

WHOAAAA fires out linch mob i think i have worded this very poorly and for this i can only apologise.

the start of this thread was not as it first seemed, as in stop all transfusion's now... it was suppose to be at the very start so day one of invention. were they a good idea or not ? have they proved there worth or would the world be better off if illness was dealt with before live begins (which took us on to the next discusion if you know your baby is going to suffer should you give birth or abort)

i can only apologise again for any confusion.

Originally Posted by Tom_the_great

WHOAAAA fires out linch mob i think i have worded this very poorly and for this i can only apologise.

the start of this thread was not as it first seemed, as in stop all transfusion's now... it was suppose to be at the very start so day one of invention. were they a good idea or not ? have they proved there worth or would the world be better off if illness was dealt with before live begins (which took us on to the next discusion if you know your baby is going to suffer should you give birth or abort)

i can only apologise again for any confusion.

Now there's a whole new can of worms!

...and do you give a transfusion to a woman who is bleeding after an abortion...

[Tom_the_great]

tell me about it this is me a nieve 22 year old talking to 3 women was only ever going to end in me = wrong.

[gruntygiggles]

Originally Posted by Fizzy Fish

Now there's a whole new can of worms!

+1

We don't live in a perfect world. Even if you have religious belief, it is undeniable that your god did not make the world the place it was cracked up to be. Else, how can you explain human suffering?

So given that the world is not perfect, and never will be, we have to do our next best and fix it as best we can. Blood transfusions included.

[SoulKiss]

Originally Posted by Tom_the_great

WHOAAAA fires out linch mob i think i have worded this very poorly and for this i can only apologise.

the start of this thread was not as it first seemed, as in stop all transfusion's now... it was suppose to be at the very start so day one of invention. were they a good idea or not ? have they proved there worth or would the world be better off if illness was dealt with before live begins (which took us on to the next discusion if you know your baby is going to suffer should you give birth or abort)

i can only apologise again for any confusion.

Usually this is reserved for duplicate threads, but

HITLER THREAD !!!

Maybe you should go read the history books about a chap in Germany in the 30s/40s that had some ideas along those lines.

Then read a bit more about the thousands of people who gave their lives so that those perfectly logical but oh, so flawed ideas didn't come to pass...

I think it may be best to leave this one at, everybody dissagrees with you Tom!!

Originally Posted by SoulKiss

Usually this is reserved for duplicate threads, but

HITLER THREAD !!!

Maybe you should go read the history books about a chap in Germany in the 30s/40s that had some ideas along those lines.

Then read a bit more about the thousands of people who gave their lives so that those perfectly logical but oh, so flawed ideas didn't come to pass...

+1

but i dont think that he is saying people should die because they are week, i think we may have slightly got the wrong end of the stick.

However that said i still think the 'stick' that we have the wrong end of is a slightly missinformed one either way

Originally Posted by Tom_the_great

have they proved there worth or would the world be better off if illness was dealt with before live begins

yes they have proved there worth as they've saved countless lives, which in turn has probably saved even more lives (their kids/parents/brothers/sisters etc).

What do you mean by illness? And by 'dealt' with, do you actually mean not dealt with, ie left to die?

Who decides who lives and who dies anyway? And what about if you're illness is curable and you can't genetically pass it on?

Would you ideally like to sterilise every single human who has any form of illness that can be passed on to your kids? An Austrian dude with a 'tache had similar ideas not long ago!